1. Motivation: what motivated the work? [3 marks]
What type of medical problem/procedure is the paper seeking to address?
What are the inherent difficulties in addressing this medical problem/procedure using
computing approaches?
2. Approach: what approach does the paper use? [5 marks]
What is the typical profile or cohort of a patient in their study?
Describe the source and type of the data used.
Describe the Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning/Deep Learning method that was
used in this paper.
What is the general role of the method in the paper?
3. Results: what were the findings of the paper? [5 marks]
What is the specific output (e.g., type of decision) of this method?
How well did the output help address the medical problem/procedure?
What would be the impact of patient outcomes using the proposed solution?
4. Contributions: describe the contributions of the work considering previous work. [4 marks]
How does the approach proposed in the paper compare with previous work?
What was novel about the approach proposed?
What is role the Clinician/Physician/Surgeon in leveraging the benefit of using the AI
method for the medical problem/procedure?
5. Limitations: are there issues about the work that should be noted? [3 marks]
What are the limitations of the AI method used for the medical problem/procedure?
Do you consider all the claims made in the paper valid? Give reasons.